Skip to content

Lucifer, by William Blake, for Dante's Inferno...
Lucifer, by William Blake, for Dante's Inferno, canto 34 (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

My new friend Felicia from has asked another great question this week.

Q. Since God is omniscient, omnipresent and omnipotent; why did He create Satan?

I love this question. And it even has some hooks to the question we played with this morning.

Perhaps I am wrong, but I have a feeling there is a fairly widely held belief that Angels were created with no free will.

We talk in Christian circles as though angels are heaven’s robots.

Or perhaps we have an upstairs – downstairs kind of impression of angels. Like they are the servant class creation, serving the needs of humans.

But I believe scriptures teach a different truth. I believe that angels are beings with a will, and with the freedom of choice much as man is. (ok – if you missed the first Q&A today, you might want to go back to it here, where I discussed the free will of man.)

You see, the way I see it, if angels did not have free will, they would not have been able to rebel in the first place – would they?

Remember God did not create an angry vengeful devil in a red suit who started his existence as an evil beast.

Lucifer was a wonderful angel of light – the head of all the angels.

How you are fallen from heaven,
O Lucifer, son of the morning!
How you are cut down to the ground,
You who weakened the nations!
For you have said in your heart:
‘I will ascend into heaven,
I will exalt my throne above the stars of God;
I will also sit on the mount of the congregation
On the farthest sides of the north;
I will ascend above the heights of the clouds,
I will be like the Most High.’
Yet you shall be brought down to Sheol,
To the lowest depths of the Pit ~ Isaiah 14:12-15 (NKJV)

He exalted himself in pride and wanted to be like God. Hmmm – sounds familiar doesn’t it – pretty much the same temptation he threw at Adam and Eve.

So we come back to - Why did God create a being that  - if He knows everything, end from the beginning and all – He knew full well would make a mess of things?

Based on my assumption that angels are free beings with choice, and options, you can see that this is a lot like saying why create Hitler, or Bin Laden, or my crabby neighbor, or – well – me for that matter. Where do you draw the line?

Thank God that He did not draw the line. Instead He planted a cross, the plan where by all of the above could have relationship restored (with the exception of Lucifer, I am pretty sure it was too late for him by the time we get to the garden.)

So what do you think? How would you answer Felicia’s question?

Join in below, or blog about it and leave us a link!

Ben NelsonThanks for stopping by today.

See you again soon.


By the way, if you have questions of your own, click on the link on the right and let us toss them around a bit.

Welcome to Friday Q&A, a brand new feature here at Another Red Letter Day!

I met Felicia on her blog very recently. I believe I found her through a twitter link. Not sure exactly. She has a wonderful blog, and I would love it if you would check it out.

A  Life  Sanctified  

Living my outrageous, audacious faith in Jesus!

She and I were talking the other day about this verse in John’s account of the raising of Lazarus in the context of what moves Jesus.

When Jesus therefore saw her weeping, and the Jews who came with her, also weeping, He was deeply moved in spirit, and was troubled, and said, “Where have you laid him?” They said to Him, “Lord, come and see.” Jesus wept. And so the Jews were saying, “Behold how He loved him!” John 11:36

The question at hand is why is Jesus weeping?

Here it is from Felicia:

I’ve been giving this some thought …why did Jesus cry? Certainly it wasn’t for Lazarus because He knew He would raise him for His Father’s glory. So was it because of the disbelief of the others? The depth of pain the others were feeling? Or perhaps the disbelief of all humanity?

I have moved around on this question a fair bit.

I agree with Felicia, that it just does not make sense to me, that Jesus was saddened by the death of Lazarus.  (On the other hand I am not sure  the logic produced by my itsy bitsy brain is a sure test of scriptural soundness) After all we know from the context that Jesus basically let Him die because He knew what He would do.

I have heard many times He was basically sympathizing with the sorrow of the others around. The prior verse does say that there was weeping on every side. Mary, clearly one of His closest earthly friends, was weeping, as were the rest of the folks gathered. Was He just caught up in the emotion of the moment?

For many years I would have probably picked the next answer. He was saddened by the unbelief of some of His closest followers. Is this perhaps one of those “when I return will I find faith on the earth” or “did you learn nothing from the loaves and the fishes” moments?

Here is another thought. I know there are times when I consider the torture Jesus went through, all the shame, the beatings, the blood, nails, thorns, mocking, spitting, slapping, finally a spear in the side, and I am moved to tears, though I am fully aware of the next chapter. Perhaps Jesus was actually sorry that His delay causes Lazarus more pain.

One interesting detail here is that the word translated “wept” is not the same word as in the verse above. That word is more appropriate for mourning and grief. The word used in “Jesus wept” might better be rendered “shed tears”. This word in this form only shows up once in the Bible. Its root is the word “tear” which is more common, is used in two of the accounts of Mary washing Jesus’ feet with her “tears.”

It is also interesting as we ponder this that a couple verses down we see this:

Jesus therefore again being deeply moved within, came to the tomb. ~ John 11:38

One of the struggles I have with Jesus doing things in reaction to emotions is that we also know of Jesus that He only does what He sees the Father do. (see John 5:19) So I will ask another question:

What is the relationship of Jesus being “deeply moved within” and the fact that He knew He was coming to raise the dead. I am convinced from the top of the story that Jesus knew Lazarus was coming out of that tomb, He had seen it with the Father. So what does the emotion have to do with it.

I know I am leaving this open ended. This is my whole plan for Friday Q&A. I am hoping for interchange. I would love it if you would interact here. What are your thoughts on the matter? I think we all learn from sharing our ideas, considering and then growing. So share away. It would even be great if you have a lot to say, just blog about it and put a link below.

Oh - and don't forget to go visit Felicia - you will be glad you did! - A  Life  Sanctified

Remember the rules:

Be polite.

Be honest.

Be gentle.

Be friendly.

Ready, GO….

If you have questions of your own you would like to toss around click the Q&A button on the side bar and we'll chat.

%d bloggers like this: